UNFAIR TO LUNA ROSSA?

I find that the press and the America’s cup reporting are unduly harsh about team Luna Rossa. The Italians (and  Team New Zealand) have been laboring under an uneven playing field. One where the rules seem to change every day.

These two teams must race, each in their turn against a no-show opponent. America’s Cup Management has chosen not to allow these unopposed races to appear on You Tube. The boats are still incredibly powerful and thrilling to watch, but it is not their fault that Team Artemis is not prepared to race. They had agreed to wait for Artemis to be ready to sail. An offer that was refused.

The behavior of the America’s Cup so far has not provided the kind of leadership one would hope for from the pinnacle of our sport. Despite my concerns it is my sincere hope that once the Cup series is completed in September, the squabbling will be forgotten; and history will move forward.

AMERICA’S CUP JUST GETS BETTER

AT THIS POINT IS IS MORE IMPORTANT TO HAVE A GOOD LAWYER THAN A GOOD SAILOR.

APPLICATION

JURY CASE AC26 JURY NOTICE JN076

AMERICA’S CUP EVENT AUTHORITY &

LUNA ROSSA CHALLENGE 2013 JURY DIRECTIONS No.1

  1. On 16th July 2013, the Jury received an Application from America’s Cup Event Authority (ACEA) filed via jurycomms72@americascup.com and thereby sent to the parties on the Service Address list for such address (‘the Parties’).
  2. ACEA claims that Luna Rossa Challenge 2013 (LR) ‘has breached Protocol Article 45.2 (Participation in Special Events) and Article 2 (Purpose and Intent) by failing, without justification, to participate in/or comply with the prescribed requirements for two Special Events related to the Louis Vuitton Cup, America’s Cup Challenge Series’.

DIRECTIONS

  1. Parties are invited to submit a Response via jurycomms72@americascup.com, no later than18h00 (PDT) 20th July 2013.
  2. ACEA may submit a Reply via jurycomms72@americascup.com, no later than 18h00 (PDT) 22nd July 2013.

ORAL HEARING

5. The Jury is mindful to have an oral hearing on 24th July commencing at 09h30 at a location to be advised. To enable the Jury to select an appropriately sized meeting room, Parties are requested to advise via jurycomms72@americascup.com by 18h00 (PDT) 22nd July as to the names of their representatives and/or observers attending. Further Directions will be issued regarding the hearing.

PENALTIES and COSTS

6. Parties will be given an opportunity to make submissions on penalties (if appropriate) and on the Award of Costs following the Decision.

David Tillett
JURY: David Tillett (Chairman), John Doerr, Josje Hofland, Graham McKenzie, Bryan Willis.

page1image448

APPLICATION

JURY CASE AC27 JURY NOTICE JN077

LUNA ROSSA CHALLENGE 2013
&
AMERICA’S CUP EVENT AUTHORITY

JURY DIRECTIONS No.1

  1. On 16th July 2013, the Jury received an Application from Luna Rossa Challenge 2013 (LR) filed via jurycomms72@americascup.com and thereby sent to the parties on the Service Address list for such address (‘the Parties’).
  2. LR claims that America’s Cup Event Authority (ACEA) ‘has breached Protocol Article 48.1(d) by altering photographs of Luna Rossa Challenge and removing the branding of our sponsor and other elements while maintaining others that still make the boat recognisable’.

DIRECTIONS

  1. Parties are invited to submit a Response via jurycomms72@americascup.com, no later than18h00 (PDT) 21st July 2013.
  2. LR may submit a Reply via jurycomms72@americascup.com, no later than 18h00 (PDT) 24th July 2013.

ORAL HEARING

5. The Jury is mindful to have an oral hearing on 26th July commencing at 09h30 at a location to be advised. To enable the Jury to select an appropriately sized meeting room, Parties are requested to advise via jurycomms72@americascup.com by 18h00 (PDT) 24th July as to the names of their representatives and/or observers attending. Further Directions will be issued regarding the hearing.

PENALTIES and COSTS

6. Parties will be given an opportunity to make submissions on penalties (if appropriate) and on the Award of Costs following the Decision.

David Tillett
JURY: David Tillett (Chairman), John Doerr, Josje Hofland, Graham McKenzie, Bryan Willis.

FIRST REAL RACE

America’s Cup: Kiwi pre-start magic leads to good old fashioned drubbing.

July 13, 2013

Even in terms of monohull America’s Cup matches of old, a delta of five minutes and 23 seconds would be a big victory. Factor in the 40 knots speeds of the new generation of AC72 catamarans and today’s win by Emirates Team New Zealand over Luna Rossa was nothing short of an unceremonious drubbing.

The Kiwis never looked like anything other than winners in today’s match after their helmsman Dean Barker out foxed his opposite number Chris Draper in the short pre-start.

Draper had sent the Italian boat screaming across the pre-start box at 40 knots plus but rather than risk a gybe which might have left him below the layline to the leeward end of the start on the way back Draper opted to tack around.

This gave Barker the split second chance to position the New Zealand boat perfectly in order to block him well enough to prevent Luna Rossa from bearing away behind their stern.

Having secured the leeward position he wanted Barker expertly held the Italian boat on his windward hip just long enough to ensure he could lead the pairing into the startline.

With a couple of seconds to the start gun, Barker put the bows down and pulled the trigger to launch the New Zealand AC72 towards the start line at almost 42 knots, leaving Draper no alternative but to follow in his wake.

Emirates Team New Zealand rounded the first mark eight seconds ahead. Both teams hung on starboard for around 30 seconds before ETNZ gybed onto port well before the boundary. 150 metres back Luna Rossa gybed on their line, a strategy they maintained for the rest of the leg.

With the Italians clearly unable to gybe as smoothly and consistently as the New Zealand crew the Kiwi advantage when they rounded the right mark of the leeward gate was up to 29 seconds.

Luna Rossa followed suit and up the first part of the first beat both teams worked the right hand side until they reached Alcatraz Island where they took advantage of a slight right hand wind bend to cross the worst of the flood tide on a long starboard tack towards the city.

Emirates Team New Zealand went all the way to the boundary before tacking, while further back the Italians’s opted to tack at the same time. Positioned further out of the tide ETNZ continued to protect their left hand positioning with a loose cover each time Luna Rossa made a dart towards the shore.

At the windward gate the New Zealand lead was up to two minutes and two seconds as they rounded the left hand mark and powered downwind past the still beating Italian boat before gybing on to port across Luna Rossa’s wake.

The Italian crew made life even harder for themselves when they failed to gybe before the right hand course boundary and picked up a stop and go penalty.

At the second leeward gate the delta was up to two minutes 47 seconds and well over 2500 metres.

From there on in the Kiwis continued to extend. On the final run they pulled off four text book flying gybes to round the leeward gate four minutes and five seconds in front.

The final victory was five minutes and 23 seconds as the Kiwis took the win and chalked up their third point of the Louis Vuitton Series.

An understandably dejected looking Luna Rossa crew finished the race on the water outside the five minute time limit from the winner and were scored Did Not Finish (DNF).

So what should we read into today’s first head to head between the Kiwis and the Italians. Not too much to be honest. The result was not a surprise, even if the scale of the New Zealand supremacy might have been.

ETNZ are as slick and accomplished as we expected them to be. They were the first of all the teams to foil their AC72 and they are much further along the learning curve in that department than anyone.

By their own admission, the Italians are still on the lower slopes of the curve, but they are working to a clear plan they think will get them up to speed in time for the semifinals of the Louis Vuitton Series. Today confirmed just how far they have to go before they can even think about seriously troubling the Kiwi contingent.

JURY DECISION : WINNERS AND LOSERS

The international jury decisi0n leaves the class rule intact. Read: HERE.   I suspect the repercussions are not done with.

Artemis Racing is disappointed that the Jury’s decision leaves uncertainty. Artemis Racing is here to compete and remains confident that a solution will be found allowing for a safe regatta that all can compete in.

Our team is working hard and we are currently in the midst of completing the structural testing of our boat. This should be completed by weeks end. Final assembly of the boat will take place next week with the goal of getting on the water in ten days time. Artemis Racing has been working intensively for two months and we are eagerly looking forward to racing.

 

Grant Dalton on America’s Cup jury decision July 11 from Sail Racing Magazine on Vimeo.

JURY STILL OUT

America’s Cup ruling delayed by divided jury

Tom FitzGerald
Updated 11:37 pm, Wednesday, July 10, 2013

1 of 6

VIEW: LARGER | HIDE
  • Regatta director Iain Murray listened to another question Tuesday July 9, 2013 about the Italian boat not participating in last Sundays opening day. In America's Cup action on San Francisco bay, the Emirates Team New Zealand catamaran had another solo effort as the Artemis team did not race because their boat is not ready. Photo: Brant Ward, The Chronicle
    Regatta director Iain Murray listened to another question Tuesday July 9, 2013 about the Italian boat not participating in last Sundays opening day. In America’s Cup action on San Francisco bay, the Emirates Team New Zealand catamaran had another solo effort as the Artemis team did not race because their boat is not ready. Photo: Brant Ward, The Chronicle

 

The jury is still out.

A five-member jury of the International Sailing Federation said Wednesday it will announce a decision Thursday on a protest by two teams in the Louis Vuitton Cup challenger series over new rules regarding rudder wings.

The decision will be posted at 11 a.m. on the Cup’s website, americascup.com

Because the jury has been deliberating the matter since Monday morning, it’s apparent that the panel has been deeply divided. Even before formally convening, the jurors had been trying to resolve the issue in mediation last week.

The jury consists of chairman David Tillett of Australia, Graham McKenzie of New Zealand, Bryan Willis of Malaysia, John Doerr of Great Britain and Josje Hofland of the Netherlands.

The announcement is expected to come a little over an hour before Luna Rossa is expected to make its first appearance of the regatta. The Italian team has said it won’t sail until the jury rules.

Meanwhile, Sweden’s Artemis Racing, the scheduled opponent, is still trying to put its boat together after a tragic wreck in May.

After a pair of solo sails by Team New Zealand, the first genuine race of the challenger series won’t come until Saturday, when Luna Rossa meets the Kiwis.

Regatta director Iain Murray had made wider, heavier rudder wings part of the new safety rules he issued May 22, two weeks after Sweden’s Artemis Racing capsized, killing British sailor Andrew “Bart” Simpson.

Emirates Team New Zealand and Luna Rossa both protested that edict on the grounds that it was a change in the class rules that required unanimous consent by the teams. They contend the change wouldn’t make the boats safer and could give Oracle Team USA a competitive advantage because of the special design of its two boats.

Murray said last week that if the jury upheld the protests he would inform the Coast Guard he doesn’t think the racing would be safe. The Coast Guard has issued a permit for the regatta but could revoke it if the regatta director deemed the racing unsafe. The regatta could not go on without a permit.

Artemis Racing CEO Paul Cayard has said that if the jury adopted the position on rudder wings that Luna Rossa and Team New Zealand advocated, Artemis would have to drop out of the competition. It would take too long to reconfigure the boat to accommodate such a change, he said.

While the jury was deliberating, America’s Cup and Louis Vuitton officials denied a report that the French retailer, the primary sponsor of the challenger series, wants a lot of its money back.

A New Zealand newspaper reported that Louis Vuitton wants $3 million refunded because only three teams entered the competition for the chance to take on defending champion Oracle Team USA.

“We are not asking for anything back,” Louis Vuitton Cup director Christine Delangersaid. “But I’m not going to discuss our contracts.”

The New Zealand Herald reported that Bruno Trouble, whom it identified as the company’s ambassador to the America’s Cup, was “not happy” with the challenger series so far.

Trouble, a former America’s Cup sailor for France, was upset that the opening day of the regatta was overshadowed by Luna Rossa’s decision not to race until its protest of the rules change was resolved. Louis Vuitton’s initial sponsorship was for $10 million, the paper said.

The company’s contract was based on at least eight teams taking part in the Louis Vuitton Cup, according to the newspaper.

America’s Cup CEO Stephen Barclay said he wouldn’t go into detail on his organization’s contracts with sponsors but said the report was “factually incorrect.”

 

INTERNATIONAL JURY LISTENS

International Jury to hear Emirates Team New Zealand and Luna Rossa applications

05/07/2013 - San Francisco (USA,CA) - 34th America's Cup -The International Jury will hear applications from Emirates Team New Zealand and Luna Rossa Challenge beginning on Monday morning.

The two cases have been consolidated and will heard together with parties being given the opportunity to speak to their submissions.

International Jury chairman David Tillett says the hearing will last as long as is necessary to hear the evidence.

“We’d like to have a decision on Wednesday,” he said.

Both Emirates Team New Zealand and Luna Rossa are arguing Regatta Director Iain Murray exceeded his authority when some of his 37 Safety Rules effectively changed the AC72 Class Rule.

The Regatta Director argues the changes are necessary to run a safe regatta and are in line with the Rules of the event.

Full bios of the International Jury are available here.

The Transpac started today from Long Beach and the Halifax race started slowly yesterday in Marblehead.